1991 
Don Kilgas, Kaukauna 
Steve Rogers, Oostburg 
Gordy Swiggum, Southern Door 
Scott Schmitz, Mineral Point 
Blain Felsman, Berlin 
Scott Tolzman, Belmont 
Don Hartman, Osceola 
John Jacobs, West Allis Central 
Randy Dammon, La Crosse Aquinas 
Kevin Casper, Coleman

1995 
Dennis Giaimo, Appleton West 
Jeff Matczak, Kaukauna 
Don Hale, Winneconne 
Steve McDaniel, Kaukauna 
Steve Hornickle, New Holstein 
Dave Moe, Hortonville 
Mike Kelley, DePere 
Gerry Peterson, Cedar Grove 
Dave McCarthy, Neenah 
Kevin Busse, Omro 
Roger Wendorf, Merrill 
Bob Sweeney, Dodgeland 
Craig Belcher, Whitefish Bay 
Wendall Bean, Whitewater 
Bob Longdin, Hamilton Sussex 
Bill Watson, Westosha Central 
Jim Haverwas, Oak Creek 
Barry Bernstein, Germantown 
Stan Weigel, Boscobel 
Tom Sobocinski, Greenfield 
John Quinlan, Whitnall 
Dave Meyer, Lomira

1997 
Jim Tomaszewski, Crivitz 
Jeff Greul, Little Chute 
Tim Brown, Phillips

1998 
Greg Aprahamian, Muskego 
Jim Brooks, Verona

1999 
Mike Buechler, Freedom

2000 
Dan Baisden, Royal

2001 
Ernie Brodsky, Melrose Mindoro 
Joe Kaster, Janesville Craig 
Bill O'Leary, Janesville Craig 
Vern Soldner, Menominee 
Chuck Rassmussen, Lancaster 
Pete Hady, North Crawford 
Bob Johnson, Milton 
Joe Kind, Pulaki 
Bob Kopecky, West Bend West 
Bill Phillipson, Pius XI 
James Refenes, Milwaukee Lutheran 
Rick Winters, Pittsville

2002 
Tim Brown, Phillips 
Jim Campbell, Shell Lake 
Kurt Weyers, Tomahawk 
Jeff DeLorme, Bonduel 
Dave Branvold, River Falls 
Jeff Hauser, Whitehall 
James Refenes, Milwaukee Lutheran 
Dave McCarthy, Neenah 
Chuck Meyer, Pecatonica

2003 
Jim Radwill, Madison Memorial 
Doug Springer, Marshall

2004 
Randy Pongratz, Mondovi 
Dave Meyer, Lomira 
Keith Morin, Greenfield 
Don Moe, Burlington 
Scott Tolzman, Belmont-Platteville 
Jim Padlock, Kenosha Tremper 
Barry Schmitt, Independence-Gilmanton 
Tim Potratz, Weyawega Fremont 
Dan Spilde, Stoughton 
John Quinlan, Whitnall 
Tim Raymond, Medford 
Barry Schmitt, Independence 
Scott Arneson, Merrill

2005 
Jim McMahon, Menomonee Falls 
Gary Skiles, Madison LaFollette 
Luke Gundrum, Ozaukee 
Dave Meyer, Lomira

2006 
Bob Empey, Stoughton 
Chris Rank, Bonduel 
Tim Bentz, Fox Valley Lutheran 
Joe Schwabe, Stratford

2007 
Eric Anderson, Viroqua

2008 
Paul Havel, Heritage Christian 
Tom Pomietlo, Chippewa Falls 
Charlie Lulloff, Kiel 
Patrick Coffeen, Laconia 
John Messenbrink, Hartland Arrowhead 
Brian Zimmerman, Marquette University High 
Tom Mathias, Darlington

2009 
Chris Hansen, Hudson 
Fred Brown, Sheboygan Falls 
Kane Krummel, Stratford 
Jamie Olson, Boyceville 
Craig Lodahl, Delavan-Darien

2010 
Jeff Slayton, Beaver Dam 
Carl McKeeth, Arcadia 
Joel Dutton, Kenosh Tremper 
Ken Reynolds, Elkhorn Area 
Jayson Nickels, Lakeside Lutheran
Darren Anderson, Clear Lake 
Chris Persike, Lodi

2011 
Dan Stephanie, Elkhart Lake-Glenbeulah 
Scott Clough, Appleton North 
Jim Nelson, Sun Prairie

2012 
Shawn Groshek, Adams-Friendship 
Tim Coldren, Brodhead Juda 
Bret Corner, Concordia
Matt Ries, Turner 
Craig Austin, Whitnall
Bob Wozniak, Verona
Robert Kostroun, Evansville/Albany

2013 
Brad Holzer, St. Croix Central 
Chris Gennrich, Hortonville 
Frank Weiss, Fort Atkinson 
Kevin Wallace, Elkhorn 
Kevin Morin, MSOE 
Randy Ferrell, West Allis Nathan Hale